The UK’s Development as a Major Marketplace for Islamic Finance
Anouar Hassoune, Standard & Poor’s – Emmanuel Volland, Standard & Poor’s – 23 Jul 2007
The UK is set to become the first non-Muslim country to be a major financial centre of Islamic finance. This article looks at the conditions that have allowed Islamic finance to grow in the UK, and how it may move forward.
Competition is heating up among the world’s financial centres to attract Islamic issuers and investors. So far, Dubai, Kuala Lumpur, Bahrain and, to a lesser extent, Riyadh and Singapore, are all well placed to capture part of the booming Islamic finance industry. The latest entrant is London, the only financial centre actively involved in Sharia-compliant market intermediation that is not in a Muslim country. London, as a financial centre, has a number of competitive advantages compared with its emerging-market counterparts, including:
* Large size and international reach.
* Deep, efficient markets, where investors can switch from one asset class to another (including in and out of sukuk).
* Liquidity in the secondary market.
* Tremendous human resources and expertise (including research, analysis, operations, and structuring capabilities).
In addition, the legal environment is robust. The tax regime applicable to sukuk coupons will make them deductible – no longer viewing them as rental payments but equivalent to interest. Announced 21 March 2007, among other initiatives pertaining to Islamic finance, this sukuk-friendly amendment to tax law in the UK stands to make London more attractive for issuing and trading sukuk, although Dubai has been so far the most active trading centre for sukuk notes. The largest sukuk to date were those issued by Dubai-based Nakheel Group for US$3.52bn early in the first quarter of 2007. These notes were listed in both Dubai and London.
The overall size of the sukuk market worldwide is estimated at nearly US$70bn,including issuance from Malaysia, Pakistan and, of course, the Middle East. However, the bulk of sukuk are over-the-counter instruments. Listed sukuk account for only 20-25% of outstanding sukuk issued worldwide, that is, US$10-15bn so far. There are more sukuk listed in Dubai than anywhere else, but the secondary market is virtually non-existent. Second is London, where the secondary market for sukuk totalled less than US$5bn at 21 March 2007. Among listed sukuk, Standard & Poor’s Ratings Services rates close to US$6bn or roughly 50% of sukuk outstanding that is listed globally. New sukuk issuance is expected to accelerate, and could reach US$20-25bn in the next five years, according to the most reasonable forecasts.
We believe that the global Islamic financial industry will benefit from the UK’s development as an attractive marketplace for Sharia-compliant financing and investment instruments – on both the wholesale and retail side. We estimate that up to 300,000 retail customers in the UK would be ready customers for Sharia-compliant banking services. The establishment of these services in the UK would extend the reach of the Islamic financial model – so far still concentrated in a few countries in the Middle East and Muslim parts of Asia. As for wholesale banking, London has the capacity to become a hub for Sharia-compliant financial flows that seek recycling in Europe. For example, Islamic investment banks such as the Bahrain-based Arcapita Bank B.S.C. and Gulf Finance House, both have offices in London where vast amounts of liquidity from the Gulf meet attractive Sharia-compliant asset classes packaged in private equity, real estate, and infrastructure funds domiciled in the more mature and stable European economies.
The UK intends to become a key player in market intermediation for sukuk. Competition from western financial centres is low, as limited appetite for Islamic finance is coming from New York, more interested in facilitating the trading of Sharia-compliant stocks, especially through the Dow Jones Islamic Index and, more recently, through the newly created family of Standard & Poor’s Sharia indices. London, on the contrary, has a wider approach to Islamic finance, encompassing a broader range of financial instruments and asset classes. For example, the Financial Services Authority (FSA) has recently licensed the European Islamic Investment Bank, a wholesale financial institution created expressly to recycle the massive amounts of institutional and private liquidity in the Gulf into Sharia-compliant asset classes originated in mature, stable, and transparent western markets.
The FSA has taken on an Islamic retail strategy in keeping with its mission that aims for inclusion. This principle aims at combating financial exclusion, that is, the incapacity or unwillingness of households to access banking services because of distance, poverty or religion.
Some UK citizens do not actively deal with banks simply because banking in the UK is based on interest, called ‘riba’ in Arabic, considered unlawful according to Sharia, or Islamic law. To prevent Muslim customers being excluded from the banking market because of their beliefs, the FSA has given its green light to established conventional banks to offer Sharia-compliant services. Both HSBC, through its Amanah brand, and Lloyds TSB already offer Islamic banking services.
The FSA has also recently licensed a fully-fledged Islamic financial institution, the Islamic Bank of Britain, to serve the UK retail market with Sharia-compliant products. For Sharia-compliant services to become more comprehensive in the UK, the country needs to offer takaful (or Islamic mutual insurance). Licensing a takaful company or allowing conventional insurers to offer takaful products could be the next step in the UK’s strategy to further enhance its position as a leading Islamic financial centre.
The UK itself might be interested in issuing sukuk notes. Such issuance would be of high interest for investors who adhere to or favour Islamic finance. If the country did so, its issuance would be the second to carry an AAA rating, after sukuk issued by the Islamic Development Bank in 2005 for US$1bn. In addition, the UK would be the third sovereign outside the Middle East to issue Sharia-compliant paper, after Malaysia in 2002 through a US$600m structure called Malaysia Global Sukuk Inc. Japan has also expressed its intention to tap liquidity in the Gulf through the issuance of Sharia-compliant notes. The German State of Saxony-Anhalt has also issued sukuk, through a vehicle called Stichting Sachsen-Anhalt Trust for €100m in 2004.
http://www.gtnews.com/article/6846.cfm
